Thursday, January 06, 2005

The civil war we want

Friedman seems to get it right today.

It needs to be clear that these so-called insurgents are not fighting to liberate Iraq from America, but rather to reassert the tyranny of a Sunni-Baathist minority over the majority there. The insurgents are clearly desperate that they not be cast as fighting a democratically elected Iraqi government - which is why they are desperately trying to scuttle the elections. After all, if all they wanted was their fair share of the pie, and nothing more, they would be taking part in the elections.

We cannot liberate Iraq, and never could. Only Iraqis can liberate themselves, by first forging a social contract for sharing power and then having the will to go out and defend that compact against the minorities who will try to resist it. Elections are necessary for that process to unfold, but not sufficient. There has to be the will - among Shiites, Sunnis and Kurds - to forge that equitable social contract and then fight for it.


The story I learned in Sunday school about the difference between giving a man a fish and teaching him how to catch his own fish somehow seems apt.

UPDATE: Looks like Instapundit plagarized this post. (That is a joke.)

No comments:

Post a Comment

COMMENT: